I am going to show you a number your marketing report probably does not have. It is your cost per booked estimate.
It is one division problem. Total marketing spend, divided by the estimates that actually landed on your calendar. Your reports do not run it for you.
Here is what the missing number looks like in a normal month:
- •You pay a marketing company every month and cannot say what one booked estimate cost you.
- •The report shows clicks and impressions. Nothing on it shows an estimate on your calendar.
- •You know what a full roof sells for. You could not say what it cost to get the phone to ring for it.
- •Two vendors each claim credit for the same job, and you have no way to settle it.
That is not a marketing problem. That is a bookkeeping problem. The fix takes your marketing spend, a count of booked estimates, and one division.
Why Clicks Cannot Tell You What a Booked Estimate Costs
A click costs money. A booked estimate earns money. Several steps sit between the two, and every step loses some of the people who started.
Follow one homeowner. She clicks your ad. She calls. Someone answers.
A time gets set. You show up and give a price. She signs. Six steps, and only the last one pays you.
Each step has its own cost and its own drop-off. Ad platform reports count clicks and contacts. That measures step one or two. It says nothing about step six.
That is why two roofers can pay the same bill and get different results. The bill tells you what you spent. Only your calendar tells you what it bought.
Who owns the booked estimate across your vendors is covered in this post on roofing marketing services and the booked estimate. This post is the math.
The Cost Per Booked Estimate Formula, Then Cost Per Signed Roof
The math is simple. Two divisions.
- •Cost per booked estimate. — Total marketing spend for the period, divided by the booked estimates in the same period.
- •Cost per signed roof. — The same total marketing spend, divided by the roofs that were signed.
The first number tells you what it costs to get a homeowner to agree to an estimate visit. The second tells you what it costs to win a roof. You need both, because a cheap booked estimate that never signs is still expensive.
Here is the math with invented round numbers. They are an illustration of the arithmetic. They are not an industry average and not a target.
| Line | Illustration |
|---|---|
| Vendor fees for the period | $3,000 |
| Ad spend paid to the platforms | $2,000 |
| Total marketing spend | $5,000 |
| Booked estimates | 20 |
| Cost per booked estimate | $250 |
| Signed roofs from those estimates | 4 |
| Cost per signed roof | $1,250 |
Line: Vendor fees for the period
- Illustration
Line: Ad spend paid to the platforms
- Illustration
Line: Total marketing spend
- Illustration
Line: Booked estimates
- Illustration
Line: Cost per booked estimate
- Illustration
Line: Signed roofs from those estimates
- Illustration
Line: Cost per signed roof
- Illustration
Divide the $5,000 by 20 booked estimates. Each one cost $250. Divide the same $5,000 by 4 signed roofs. Each roof cost $1,250 to win.
Now compare that to what a roof leaves you. Say each signed roof leaves $4,000 after materials, labor and job costs, before marketing. Subtract the $1,250. The roof left $2,750.
One warning. A roof signed this month often came from an estimate booked last month. Run the numbers on three months together, not one, so the timing evens out.
Where to Get the Two Numbers: Call Tracking and the Estimate Log
You already have the spend. It sits in your bank and card statements and in the invoices you pay. Add up everything you paid for marketing in the period.
Use what left your account, not what a proposal promised. If a bill includes work you never agreed to, the signs your marketing company is billing you for more than you bought explain what to look for. Until it is corrected, the money still counts in your total.
The booked estimates are the number you have to build. You need a simple estimate log. One row for every booked estimate.
| Column | What to write |
|---|---|
| Date booked | The day the estimate went on the calendar |
| Source | Where the call came from, taken from call tracking |
| Held | Yes or no. Did the estimate visit happen |
| Outcome | Signed, lost, or still open |
| Job price | The price on the signed contract |
Column: Date booked
- What to write
Column: Source
- What to write
Column: Held
- What to write
Column: Outcome
- What to write
Column: Job price
- What to write
The Held column shows how many booked estimates were actually run, which matters for no-shows. Call tracking fills in the Source column. It records where each call came from, so you are not guessing which search, listing or ad made the phone ring.
As a backup, ask every caller how they found you. A caller's memory is a weak record. Use it to check the tracking, not to replace it.
This also settles the fight over credit. Two vendors can claim the same job, but your log holds one row for it. Count each booked estimate once, under the source of the call that booked it. Pick that rule once and keep it every month.
What a Bad Number Tells You
A bad cost per booked estimate is a symptom. The fix depends on which half of the math is off.
- •The spend is high and the calls are few. — The money is buying clicks and impressions that do not turn into phone calls. Run the same math for each source. One source may cost far more per booked estimate than the others, and that is the one to question first.
- •The calls are many and the booked estimates are few. — People are calling and the calendar is not filling. Count how many of those calls reached voicemail. What a missed call costs your roofing company shows how to put a dollar figure on each one.
- •The booked estimates are cheap and the signed roofs are not. — The marketing did its job and the money was lost after the booking. That is a different problem, and it needs a different fix than more spend.
- •The number jumps around. — With only a few booked estimates in a month, one more or one less moves the number a lot. Use three months together before you act.
There is a fifth result. You cannot fill in the log at all. That is not a bad number. That is no number, and it means you are paying for a result you cannot see.
Whatever your number is, hold it against your break-even. Above it, the marketing costs more than the roofs return. Below it, the marketing is paying for itself.
What to Do With It Next Month
You do not need software for this. You need one sitting at the start of the month.
- •Add up the spend. — Pull every marketing payment from your statements for the last three months.
- •Count the estimates. — Fill in the estimate log for the same three months, with the source of each one.
- •Divide twice. — Total spend by booked estimates. Total spend by signed roofs.
- •Find your break-even. — Profit on a roof before marketing, times the share of booked estimates that become signed roofs. That is the most you can pay per booked estimate.
- •Question the worst source. — Run the cost per booked estimate for each source. Ask the vendor behind the highest one to explain the number. Do not cut anything on one month of data.
- •Keep the rules fixed. — Count spend the same way and credit sources the same way every month, so a change from one month to the next means something.
Run it once and you will know something your marketing reports do not show. Run it every month and you will know which dollars to keep spending.
Frequently Asked Questions
►How do I calculate cost per booked estimate?
Add up everything you paid for marketing in a period. Divide that total by the number of estimates booked in the same period. For example, $5,000 spent and 20 booked estimates is $250 each. Those numbers are invented to show the arithmetic. Use three months together so the timing evens out.
►What is a good cost per booked estimate for a roofer?
It depends on your own margin, and here is the number it depends on. Take the profit on a roof before marketing and multiply it by the share of booked estimates that become signed roofs. The result is the most you can pay per booked estimate and still break even. An average from someone else's books knows nothing about your margin or your signed-roof rate.
►What should I count as marketing spend?
Count everything you paid to get homeowners to call. That means vendor fees, ad spend paid to the platforms, call tracking, and website costs tied to marketing. Leave out the cost of doing the job. If you pay someone to answer calls or book estimates, decide once whether to include that pay. Then count it the same way every month.
►How do I know which source a booked estimate came from?
Use call tracking as the main record, because it shows where each call came from. Write that source in your estimate log when the estimate is booked. Ask the caller how they found you as a backup. If two vendors claim the same estimate, count it once, under the source of the call that booked it.
A cost you cannot measure is a guess, and a guess is not an investment. The Search-to-Booked Roofing System™ includes Search-To-Call Tracking from the Foundation tier, so you can see which search produced which call and run this number from real data.

